20 Apr 2024
Saturday 5 May 2018 - 10:19
Story Code : 303643

Trump exit from Iran nuclear deal enters uncharted territory

AP| Josh Lederman and Matthew Lee: Its not as simple as just saying were out of the Iran nuclear deal.


If President Donald Trump follows through on his threat to pull the U.S. out of the Iran nuclear deal on May 12, the rest of the world will be thrust into uncharted territory, forced to navigate a complex web of U.S. sanctions that were lifted under the landmark accord but would ostensibly be put back in place.


Would Trump re-impose sanctions on those who do business with Iran? How quickly? And would Europe follow suit? How would Iran respond? And what happens to Irans pre-existing obligations to allow nuclear inspections?


Its going to be very complicated, said Ama Adams, who advises clients on international sanctions compliance at the law firm Ropes & Gray. There are lots of opportunities to trip up and make mistakes. Its going to be a period of a lot of activity and flurry.


A look at possible scenarios for what stays and goes if Trump exits the accord:


U.S. SANCTIONS


Under the 2015 deal, the United States issued waivers to longstanding sanctions punishing Iran for its nuclear program. Iran, in turn, restricted its program and allowed more inspections.


Trump has essentially two options for re-imposing sanctions.


On May 12, he faces a deadline on whether to renew the waivers that eased one basket of sanctions: those on Irans central bank, intended to hit Iranian oil exports. Another basket of sanctions waivers are up for renewal on July 11, focusing on more than 400 specific Iranian companies, individuals and business sectors.


One of Trumps options, being called the nuclear option by some experts, would re-impose all the sanctions at once even those not scheduled for renewal until July. That would put the U.S. in immediate violation of the deals terms, which say sanctions remain lifted as long as Iran is complying with its terms. So far, the International Atomic Energy Agency, the U.N.s nuclear monitoring agency, has said Iran is complying, and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo agrees.


A second option: re-imposing only the central bank sanctions. That would start a 180-day clock in which companies or countries would be expected to reduce their purchases of oil from Iran. Those that dont would ultimately be penalized by Washington.


Why not restore all the sanctions at once? Proponents of doing it piece by piece say it would give the U.S. more leverage to bring about a fix to the deal so that Trump could stay in after all. Trump has long said the deal needed to be strengthened or abandoned, but efforts with European allies to strengthen it havent yet succeeded. With sanctions about to kick in again in 180 days, there might be enough pressure on the Iranians, the Europeans and other members of the deal to give in to Trumps demands, proponents say.


But supporters of the nuclear deal say thats not a viable option because the U.S., by starting the 180-day clock, would have already breached the deal. And as soon as Trump announces sanctions will be coming back, companies will immediately start shutting down their business with Iran. That means Iran would suffer from lost business and could decide to walk away from the deal itself.


Adams, the sanctions attorney, said some companies have already started winding down business in anticipation that Trump may re-impose sanctions.


__


THE REST OF THE WORLD


What would Europe do? Germany, France and the U.K. have suggested they have no intention of leaving the deal, even if the U.S. withdraws. But it might not matter much. The global financial system is so interconnected and so tied to New York that it would be almost impossible for anyone anywhere in the world to continue their business with Iran without risk of violating U.S. sanctions. For example, Europe businesses owned or controlled by American parent companies would breach the sanctions if they didnt cut off Iran.


Its a major dilemma for European businesses, made even more complicated if the European Union decides to invoke a measure put in place in the 1990s to counter the U.S. embargo on Cuba. The EU can use those regulations to prohibit European companies from complying with some U.S. sanctions. That puts businesses in the position of choosing whether to defy the United States or the EU.


__


IRANS RESPONSE


Irans leaders have been coy, although Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif told The Associated Press last week Iran would most likely abandon the deal if Trump withdraws. Yet the key question is whether Iran would resume nuclear activities, such as enrichment and processing, beyond the limits that were imposed by the deal and how aggressively.


How would the world even know? If the deal collapses, Iran would no longer be bound by the rigorous inspections regime by the IAEA that it agreed to in the deal. That regime included the so-called Additional Protocol, which expanded the IAEAs access to sites in Iran, including giving inspectors insight into all parts of the nuclear fuel cycle, access on short notice to all buildings at an acknowledged nuclear site, and the right to obtain samples from military sites.


Even without the nuclear deal, Iran would still be required to allow a more limited regime of inspections required by the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty, which Iran has signed. But its unclear how rigorously Iran would comply. After all, alleged cheating and delay tactics by Iran were a major concern prior to the 2015 deal. And Iranian officials havent explicitly ruled out the possibility that if Trump blows up the nuclear deal, Iran may also leave the Nonproliferation Treaty.


Then theres the question of whether Iran, feeling swindled on a deal the U.S. itself brokered, would take other steps to retaliate such as ballistic missile tests or more support for militant groups abroad.


Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

https://theiranproject.com/vdci5pappt1auq2.ilct.html
Your Name
Your Email Address